The Best Pizza in Pigeon Forge: Top 3 Restaurants

September 10, 2022

Vacationers who are craving pizza in Pigeon Forge, TN won’t have to look far to find a great pie! Our Smoky Mountain city is home to a number of eateries that make mouthwatering pizzas. To help you make the most of your getaway, Auntie Belham’s Cabin Rentals has put together a guide to three restaurants that serve the best pizza in Pigeon Forge.

1. Mellow Mushroom

The Mellow Mushroom makes pizzas that are in a class all their own. Unlike restaurants that seek to mimic the New York or Chicago styles of pizza, the Mellow Mushroom breaks away from tradition to create a pie that is truly unique. What sets Mellow Mushroom pizza apart from the rest is its crust, which is made from spring water dough and coated with garlic butter and parmesan cheese.

There are two Mellow Mushroom locations in Pigeon Forge that are within a mile of each other. If you are looking for a traditional dining experience with a server and a full menu, we recommend visiting the Mellow Mushroom on the Parkway . However, if you are looking for a quicker meal, consider eating at the Mellow Mushroom Select at The Island . The first of its kind, this restaurant lets you order from a smaller menu right at the counter. Mellow Mushroom definitely has some of the best pizza in Pigeon Forge!

2. Big Daddy’s Pizzeria

Big Daddy’s Pizzeria is another place that can confidently claim the mantle of “Best Pizza in Pigeon Forge”. This popular restaurant makes all of its pies with hand pulled dough, homemade tomato sauce, and the freshest ingredients. The secret to Big Daddy’s success is its 550 degree wood-fired brick oven, which creates pizza with a perfect crispy thin crust.

Big Daddy’s is also known for the impressive variety of pizzas it offers. In addition to classic pizzas like Pepperoni and Meatball, this restaurant also serves speciality pies, including the Chicken Florentine Pizza (made with spinach artichoke dip, chicken, and roma tomatoes) and the Taco Pie (made with refried beans, ground beef, and cheddar cheese).

3. Smoky Mountain Brewery

While the Smoky Mountain Brewery is most famous for its locally brewed beers, it also offers a variety of delicious pizzas for guests to enjoy. Standout pies at the Brewery include the Baker’s Choice Pizza (made with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, sausage, and green peppers) and the Brewmaster Pizza (made with a four-cheese blend, roasted chicken, garlic roasted tomatoes, and spinach).

Located in the Shops at Walden’s Landing, the Smoky Mountain Brewery is the perfect place to spend an evening with your friends or family. Sports fans will find over 20 TVs to watch the big game, and music lovers will enjoy the nightly live entertainment.

When you stay with Auntie Belham’s Cabin Rentals, you will be just a short drive away from the best pizza in Pigeon Forge. With everything from 1 bedroom cabins for romantic getaways to 9 bedroom cabins for family reunions, we are sure to have the perfect property for your vacation. To start planning your next escape in the mountains, browse our selection of cabin rentals in Pigeon Forge.